Medicolegal assessment and reports

Request Medicolegal Services

Require an independent medical examination, permanent impairment assessment or expert opinion? Submit a referral to arrange a medicolegal report with Dr Simon Clark.

What is a Medicolegal Assessment?

A medicolegal assessment is an independent medical examination conducted by a qualified specialist to provide an objective opinion on injury, illness, or disability for legal, compensation, or insurance purposes.

Unlike a treating physician, a medicolegal examiner does not provide treatment or ongoing care. Their role is to deliver an evidence-based, impartial report that assists lawyers, insurers, employers, and courts in making informed decisions.

Dr Simon Clark is an experienced spinal neurosurgeon who provides medicolegal reports and independent medical opinions on spinal and neurological conditions, including injuries sustained through workplace accidents, motor vehicle accidents, and other trauma.

Types of Medicolegal Reports

  • Independent Medical Examination (IME): An impartial assessment of injury or illness by an independent specialist to assist in legal, compensation or insurance proceedings.
  • Joint Medical Examination (JME): Conducted under TAC guidelines, with identical reports provided to both parties — an efficient and timely solution.
  • Medical Negligence Report: An independent opinion on the standard of medical care provided in alleged malpractice cases.
  • Expert Witness Report: Detailed, evidence-based reports prepared for court proceedings, supported by oral testimony where required.
  • File Review & Written Opinion: A specialist review of existing medical records and documentation, providing an opinion without a physical examination.
  • Fitness for Duty Assessment: Determines whether an individual is medically fit to perform their regular work duties.
  • Telehealth Assessment: Remote medicolegal consultations available nationally for those unable to attend in person.

Who Requests Medicolegal Reports?

  • Law firms & solicitors — plaintiff and defendant litigators handling personal injury, workers compensation, and medical negligence claims
  • Insurers & claims managers — WorkSafe Victoria, TAC, Comcare, and private insurers
  • Self-insured employers — requiring independent opinions on workplace injury and fitness for duty
  • Superannuation trustees — for TPD and income protection claims
  • Courts & tribunals — requiring impartial expert witness testimony
  • Government agencies — including DVA for military compensation assessments

What to Expect at Your Assessment

A medicolegal examination is conducted by an independent specialist who has no prior treating relationship with you. The purpose is to assess your injury or condition and provide an objective report to the requesting party.

  • Medical history review: Dr Clark will take a thorough history of your injury, symptoms, and any prior treatment or investigations.
  • Physical examination: A focused neurological and spinal examination relevant to the condition being assessed.
  • Document review: All relevant medical records, imaging reports, and specialist correspondence will be reviewed prior to your appointment.
  • Report preparation: A detailed, evidence-based report will be prepared and provided to the requesting party, typically within 10 business days.

Please note: Dr Clark acts as an independent examiner and cannot provide treatment recommendations or act as a treating doctor in the context of a medicolegal appointment.

Dr Clark's Medicolegal Expertise

Dr Simon Clark is a consultant spinal neurosurgeon with extensive experience providing independent medicolegal opinions across a wide range of spinal and neurological conditions. He has been engaged by law firms, insurers, and self-insured employers throughout Australia.

His medicolegal expertise includes:

  • Spinal cord and nerve root injuries
  • Disc herniation and degenerative spinal disease
  • Traumatic brain and spinal injuries (MVA, workplace)
  • Failed spinal surgery / post-operative complications
  • Chronic pain and permanent impairment assessment
  • Cauda equina syndrome
  • Medical negligence in spinal and neurosurgical procedures

Dr Clark provides reports that are clear, evidence-based, and defensible in legal proceedings. He is available for expert witness attendance at court where required.

Medicolegal Referral Process

Submitting a medicolegal referral to Dr Simon Clark is straightforward. The following steps outline what to expect:

  1. Submit a referral: Complete the referral form on this page or contact the rooms directly. Please include the purpose of the report, the relevant legal context, and all available medical records and imaging.
  2. Appointment scheduling: Our team will contact you to arrange a convenient appointment time, available in person at our Melbourne consulting rooms or via telehealth.
  3. Examination: Dr Clark will review the provided documentation and conduct an independent examination of the patient.
  4. Report delivery: A comprehensive medicolegal report will be prepared and delivered to the referring party, typically within 10 business days of the assessment.
  5. Expert witness: If required, Dr Clark is available to provide oral evidence at court, tribunal, or mediation proceedings.

For urgent matters or questions about the referral process, please contact our rooms directly.

Referrals From Legal & Insurance Professionals Welcome

Submit a Medicolegal Enquiry

To arrange a medicolegal examination with Dr Simon Clark, please complete the referral form. Include the purpose of the assessment, the relevant legal or compensation context, and any available medical records or imaging. Our team will be in touch to confirm availability and schedule your appointment.

Have a general Enquiry?

If you don’t have a referral yet and would like to reach out with a general enquiry, please use go to our contact page.

What happens after you submit

Once we receive your request, our team will review the information and contact you to discuss appointment options and what we need next (for example, imaging reports). If we need anything further to progress your request, we’ll let you know.

Name(Required)